With development squeezing isolated populations of black bears into fragmented pockets, critics warn that Florida’s expanding bear hunt could push vulnerable animals past a point of no return.

WORDS BY ALAYNA ROBERTSON | autumn 2026 ‘earth word’ mentee

EDITS BY AVERY SCHUYLER NUNN

OIL-ON-CANVAS IMAGES: Morning in a Pine Forest © 1889 Ivan Shishkin || The Great Florida Marsh © 1886 Martin Johnson Heade

The night air has finally cooled in south central Florida, where a female black bear roots through the dense understory for ripe saw palmetto and pokeweed berries. She’s entered hyperphagia, a biologically programmed hunger to prepare her for winter denning and, if she eats enough, the two cubs that will arrive by January. 


Pine needles and palm fronds rustle beneath her paws, her nose hovering inches off the ground. Nearby, the perpetual whoosh of Route 27 carries through the trees. The forest floor is lit only by the stars and the faintest rhythmic flicker of her new necklace—a GPS collar that scientists rely on to track her movements and study her elusive relatives. She is one of an estimated 98 individuals that belong to this distinct subpopulation, and in a few weeks, her home will open to 215 hunters who won a permit in the 2026 bear hunt lottery. 


This December marks Florida’s second sanctioned black bear hunt since the contentious 2015 season. Three years after the Florida black bear was removed from the threatened species list, hunters killed 304 bears across the state—including 38 reproductive females—forcing officials to shut down a planned seven-day hunt in just two days. Although the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) built its quotas on 13-year-old population data and viewed the rapid harvest as proof of a thriving population, local quotas were shattered in two of the designated bear harvest zones (BHZs), with the East Panhandle zone exceeding its limit nearly threefold. Despite public outrage shelving the hunt for ten years, and 81% of Florida voters opposing its return in 2025, the state reinstated the season before the year was out.


The FWC reasons that the hunt is a necessary management tool amidst Florida’s large and growing bear population. A 2025 study revealed rapid growth rates in the East Panhandle region, driven primarily by the high survival rate of adult female bears and female-biased sex ratio. As males use larger home ranges, traversing longer distances in search of food and mates, they are disproportionately killed in vehicle collisions.


Vehicle strikes, poaching, and conflict responses kill an estimated 300 Florida black bears each year. Because males make up 70% of non-hunting deaths, the FWC argues a hunt would help balance the population. While the study informed the FWC's 2025 quotas and rationale, it focused on the state's largest, most connected subpopulation living in largely unfragmented conservation areas. As a result, scientists warn the findings don’t reflect statewide growth rates.With the last statewide abundance data being more than a decade old—and updated figures not expected until 2028—critics and residents argue reinstating the season is dangerously premature.


Florida was once home to over 11,000 black bears (Ursus americanus floridanus), its own distinct subspecies that co-evolved alongside Florida’s longleaf pines, scrub oaks, marshes, prairies, and blackwater swamps. They are slightly larger in size than some of their northern counterparts and possess unique skeletal characteristics that reflect their 80% plant diet. They are most active during the summer breeding season and fall feast, following the seasonal cycles of ancestral foods like saw palmetto, swamp tupelo, and hickory nuts, alongside searching for colonial insects and scavenging occasionally on carrion. These omnivorous habitat generalists once roamed the entire peninsula from the northern border to the Florida Keys, but habitat loss and fragmentation have since severed them into seven isolated subpopulations. 


Compounded by unregulated hunting, habitat loss drove their numbers to fewer than 500 bears by the 1970s, leaving them in only 18% of their historical range. Following the birth of the Endangered Species Act, Florida black bears were listed as a threatened species in 1974, and protection and conservation efforts have since increased their numbers to roughly 4,000. 


“The recovery of black bears in Florida is one of the great success stories, like the recovery of alligators, eagles and many other wildlife species.” says Brian Scheick, Bear Research Program Coordinator with the FWC. 


Scheick, a taller version of the child glued to Wild Kingdom on his TV screen, has been doing bear research for over 30 years—the last 25 of which have been with the FWC. The FWC Bear Research Program operates separately from the FWC Bear Management Program and Board of Commissioners, which set population management rules. His statewide research uses hair snare and GPS-collar data to track movement patterns, home ranges, survival rates, and threats from habitat loss and fragmentation. Those findings help the Florida Department of Transportation pinpoint road-crossing hotspots and plan wildlife passages. He studies all subpopulations, from the largest in the north to one of the smallest in the South Central (Highlands-Glades) Bear Management Unit.


The Highlands-Glades subpopulation lives amongst small fragmented islands of natural forests, surrounded by a sea of urban development, private land, and agriculture. Their genetic diversity is low, and Scheick’s research suggests a minimum of three new migrants per generation are required to brave the perilous journey along the roadsides to prevent further genetic loss. While a female-biased sex ratio signals a thriving population in places like the East Panhandle, here—combined with low numbers, high male mortality, and severe habitat loss—it points toward a spiral toward extinction.

Historically, Florida black bears ranged across the entire state—from dense pine flatwoods and upland hardwood hammocks to expansive wetlands and coastal scrub—but human development and habitat loss have fragmented their population into isolated pockets: West Panhandle (120 bears), East Panhandle (1,060 bears), North (500 bears), Central (1,200 bears) Big Bend (30 bears), South (1,040 bears), and South Central (98 bears, also known as Highlands-Glades; HGS).

Sheick is hopeful that improving habitat connectivity through protected corridors will help increase diversity and allow black bears to thrive, however the question remains of what “protected” means for bears in these spaces. The Florida Wildlife Corridor, inspired in part by a male HGS bear, M34’s enlightening 500 mile journey, is a widely supported initiative to connect 18 million acres of land for safe wildlife movement–yet bear hunting is permitted within its boundaries. Land protections are also losing ground to unchecked development, which is projected to destroy more than 50% of the HGS’s remaining natural habitat in the coming decades. 


“I see black bears as the defenders of our forests, because when we protect black bears, that means we're protecting their habitat,” says Sarah Younger, co-chair of the Conservation Committee at the Sierra Club Florida Chapter.


As black bears find home in most of Florida’s varied landscapes, protecting bears also protects Florida’s wilderness, and others that find refuge there including endangered species like Florida gopher tortoises and Florida panthers. Importantly, Younger points out, these wild places are just as vital to human well-being, providing clean air, water, and permeable soils to protect us from the effects of flooding and sea level rise.  


In its 2025 hunt report, the FWC justified the season by stating there will not be enough bear habitat to sustain human and bear population growth as they are. Younger wonders why the data on habitat carrying capacity hasn’t been shared publicly. As more of Florida’s riparian forests and wetlands are steamrolled into strip malls and suburbs each year, bears lose quality habitat and venture further in search of food, and human-bear interactions are increasing as a result. With habitats shrinking and bears being pushed closer to neighborhoods, critics wonder if the hunt quotas will consequently continue to rise. 


“There can be a better future shared between people and bears if communities adopt BearWise practices and continue to reduce the availability of trash by using bear-resistant trash cans and dumpsters,” says Scheick. 


While agency officials frame the hunt as a tool to curb rising human-wildlife encounters, Younger points out that permitted hunting occurs deep in the woods—not in the suburban neighborhoods where habituated bears rummage through unsecured trash cans. The FWC acknowledges that the hunt alone won’t solve this issue, and that conflict prevention strategies are still necessary. The 2025 hunt generated $835,695 for State Game Trust Fund, which the Commission claims will be used for conservation initiatives, but specifics on how much will be allocated to assisting communities in BearWise practices has not been identified. Younger nods to the correlation between the high revenue of the hunt and the Board of Commissioners lack of background in natural sciences, but strong ties to the housing and development trade.


The FWC came into the 2025 season promising stricter regulations and lower quotas. A lottery system was introduced, giving the public the opportunity to win 187 permits to hunt in designated BHZs (1 bear per permit) over the course of 22 days. Mid-application, officials slashed that total to 172 after discovering the Osceola subpopulation had been overestimated by two-thirds.  The season came to an end with 52 bears harvested, but 52 permits went unused as a result of The Sierra Club Florida Chapter’s “Spare a bear, Bag a tag” initiative. 


“We are not opposed to hunting at the Sierra Club,” says Younger. “We feel very strongly that in order to manage wildlife properly, you should have science. And these hunts have quite evidently not been managed through science.”


When the Commission voted to revive the hunt at its 2025 public meeting, Younger was devastated, but quick to mobilize. She and her team organized the lottery campaign, urging conservationists and community members to buy up as many application slots as possible to intercept tags before hunters could claim them. After a successful first year, Younger is confident that advocates will show up for the bears again this season.  


Even without updated population data, the 2026 hunt is right around the corner, and the number of permits has increased to 215, which Younger attributes to her campaign’s success the previous year. The 2026 season will also grant special permissions for hunting on private land through The Private Lands Bear Harvest Program. Land owners with 5,000 or more acres can skip the lottery system, hunt for a longer duration, and obtain up to three permits depending on acreage. Land owners will also be allowed to use baited feeding stations to lure bears, affirming the agency’s popular conservation slogan: “a fed bear is a dead bear”. While the hunt will not occur within the man-made borders of the South Central BMU, hunters will be permitted to wait on the very edges, and sneak in through privately owned lands that the HGS population mostly inhabits. The 2026 season will also allow the harvest of GPS collared bears.


The FWC will report to the scene for all bears harvested throughout the season, collecting data on sex, age, weight, body measurements, and genetics. While harvest data contributes to what we know about the demographics and distribution of Florida black bears, conservationists wonder what mysteries may go undiscovered now that GPS collared ambassadors like M34 may be lost, whose journey inspired the dream of an unbroken wild Florida, a shared home amidst the pines, marshes, and swamps.


“We have paradise right here, we just have to learn how to coexist,” Younger urges. “And we could learn a lot from listening to those who came before us on this land.”